Grimsby vs Man Utd: Historic Carabao Cup Upset (12-11 Penalties)

It’s the kind of night that makes the Carabao Cup special: a League Two side taking on one of the world’s biggest clubs, and winning. On August 27, 2025, Grimsby Town did just that, knocking Manchester United out in a penalty shootout that stretched to 23 spot-kicks. The result not only sent shockwaves through English football but rewrote the head-to-head history between these two sides.

Final score: 2‑2 after extra time, Grimsby won 12‑11 on penalties ·
Date: August 27, 2025 ·
Venue: Blundell Park, Cleethorpes ·
Competition: EFL Cup (Carabao Cup) second round ·
Grimsby league position: League Two (fourth tier) ·
All‑time meetings: 37 previous matches before this game

The match snapshot below provides key details.

Have Grimsby ever beaten Manchester United?

Historical head‑to‑head record

Before this match, Grimsby Town and Manchester United had met 37 times in all competitions dating back to 1890. The record stood at 24 United wins, 10 draws, and 3 Grimsby wins – but that total is misleading. Every one of those Grimsby victories came before 1940, and none had been recorded in the modern era. The 2025 Carabao Cup tie was the first time the two clubs had faced each other since 1973 (ESPN UK).

The pattern: for more than half a century, Manchester United had treated Grimsby as a footnote. The Mariners had not even scored against United in their last five meetings. But the stats line shifted dramatically on this August night.

The 2025 Carabao Cup result

Grimsby Town beat Manchester United 12‑11 on penalties after a 2‑2 draw in the second round of the Carabao Cup. This was the first time Grimsby had ever beaten United in 38 attempts across all competitions (Sky Sports).

What this means: a League Two side – the fourth tier of English football – eliminated a Premier League giant. The historic context amplifies the shock: no lower‑league club had knocked out Manchester United from the League Cup since 2011.

The implication: for Grimsby, this win breaks a decades-long drought and sets a new standard.

How did Man United lose to Grimsby?

Match summary

Grimsby took a shock lead in the 22nd minute when Charles Vernam beat André Onana at his near post. Tyrell Warren doubled the lead in the 30th minute after Onana failed to punch clear a cross (Sky Sports). Manchester United pulled one back through Bryan Mbeumo in the 75th minute, and Harry Maguire equalised in the 89th minute to force extra time (ESPN UK).

Penalty shootout details

After 30 minutes of extra time without further goals, the match went to penalties. The shootout lasted 23 kicks, one of the longest in Carabao Cup history (YouTube / highlight description). The decisive moment came when Bryan Mbeumo hit the crossbar, giving Grimsby a 12‑11 victory (ESPN UK).

The trade‑off: United dominated possession but lacked cutting edge. Grimsby’s discipline from 12 yards sealed a result that the stats sheet alone cannot explain.

Why did Man Utd lose to Grimsby?

Post‑match analysis by Ruben Amorim

Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim described the defeat as a “new low” for his tenure, telling reporters that he accepted full responsibility (Sky Sports). Amorim had rotated his squad but still fielded a strong side including internationals. The manager pointed to individual errors – particularly from goalkeeper André Onana – as decisive.

Key factors in the defeat

Sky Sports reported that Onana was at fault for both Grimsby goals: he allowed Vernam’s shot through his near post and missed a punch on the cross that led to Warren’s tap‑in (Sky Sports). Grimsby’s tactical discipline was also credited: they defended deep, stayed compact, and trusted their chances from 12 yards.

The implication: for Amorim, this result adds pressure in a season where cup progress was expected. For United, the pattern of losing to lower‑division sides in cup competitions is a recurring flaw.

Penalties taken: 23 ·
Penalty accuracy: 96% (22 scored, 1 miss) ·
Longest shootout in Carabao Cup history (unofficial): yes

The pattern: United’s cup exits to lower-tier sides have become a recurring flaw.

Timeline: The night Grimsby shocked the world

Five key moments capture how the upset unfolded.

• 27 August 2025, 22′: Charles Vernam gives Grimsby the lead (1‑0) – Onana beaten at near post (ESPN UK)
• 30′: Tyrell Warren makes it 2‑0 after Onana misses a cross (Sky Sports)
• 75′: Bryan Mbeumo heads United back into the match (2‑1) (ESPN UK)
• 89′: Harry Maguire equalises – 2‑2 (ESPN UK)
• Penalties: 23 kicks, Mbeumo hits the bar – Grimsby win 12‑11 (ESPN UK)

Why this matters: the sequence shows a team that twice fought back from two goals down only to fall short from the spot. The stat line – 2‑2, 12‑11 on penalties – encapsulates a night where United’s resilience was not enough.

Clarity: What’s confirmed and what’s still uncertain

What this means: the narrative of this match rests on confirmed details, but broader records remain unverified.

“It’s a new low for us. I take full responsibility.”

Ruben Amorim, Manchester United manager (quoted by Sky Sports)

“The lads were brilliant – disciplined, committed, and they deserved it.”

David Artell, Grimsby Town manager (cited in match report by Sky Sports)

For Ruben Amorim, the consequence is clear: another early cup exit that will amplify questions about his squad management and tactical flexibility. For Grimsby, the reward is a third‑round berth and a place in club folklore – but the real test will be whether they can build on this historic night rather than being remembered only as giant‑killers.

For a detailed breakdown of the match, see the historic penalty shootout which covers the full 13-round shootout drama.

Frequently asked questions

Related reading: Southampton vs Arsenal Stats: FA Cup Quarter-final Result · West Ham vs Sunderland A.F.C. Stats: H2H, Results, History